I like restoring old planes so that they become almost as good as a new one of good quality.
A while ago I bought a smoothing plane, a Stanley 4 ½, on eBay to set up for difficult timber. I spent a few days getting it in order. Here is a short description of the work.
I started by taking it apart and cleaning all the parts. Mineral spirits, a brass brush or an old toothbrush and patience usually do the job. This plane was not very rusty, so I did not have to give it a bath in citric acid or another rust-removing liquid.
It is important that the frog, which holds the iron in place, sits firmly and has a completely flat surface where the iron rests. I usually mark the mating surfaces between the sole and the frog with a marker pen and rub them against each other to see how large the contact area is. If it is less than about 50 %, I scrape and file the shiny areas on the sole a little and then repeat the procedure. The shiny areas are the ones in contact with each other, so they are higher than the rest and prevent the remaining surface from making contact. It can take a few rounds until the contact area is large enough. In this case I was lucky and could go straight to the next step: putting a little grinding powder between the parts and rubbing for a while. That gave almost 100 % contact! I used aluminium oxide (90 grit), a common loose abrasive. I bought my tin at Axminster when I passed by a couple of years ago, but valve grinding paste works well too.
I flattened the top of the frog with wet-and-dry paper on a sheet of plate glass until it was smooth. I started with 120 grit and continued with 240 and 400. Then that was enough.
Another important detail is that the cap iron fits tightly against the iron. By finding a suitable small offcut you can prop up the back end of it to get a good angle, and hone the front edge sharp on wet-and-dry paper on glass. Once the cap iron is mounted on the iron, you can hold it up to the light and check that no light shows between cap iron and iron.
I then put the cap iron in a honing guide and honed the front edge at 45 degrees (also from 120 to 400 grit paper).
The mouth of this plane was rather ugly and crooked, so I chose to file it open a little. I scribed a line, clamped the plane at a 15-degree tilt and carefully filed to the line.
I am quite happy with the result of the filing and the adjustment of the frog. A 0.20 mm feeler gauge just fits in front of the iron.
After refitting the cleaned and waxed tote and knob and putting the blade in place, it is time to flatten the sole. It is important that the blade is in place and that the lever cap holds it with the right pressure. The iron must of course be retracted so that it does not protrude and get ground away! Flattening the sole takes time, but it is worth the effort, because the flatness of the sole determines how thin a shaving the plane can take. Here too I use sandpaper on glass. Since the sole was quite uneven, I started with 80 grit and toiled for quite a while. I drew a grid with the marker pen to see where I was removing metal.
There is a risk of rounding the sole when trying to flatten it. To reduce the risk of making the sole banana-shaped along its length, I make sure to pull almost half the plane over the end of the paper before reversing and pulling the other way.
The grip is important too. You should apply pressure straight down onto the paper, i.e. keep your hands on top of the plane and push, rather than holding it the way you normally do when planing. That also reduces the risk of rounding the sole in the other direction. (If it starts to get rounded here, you can straighten it by using a narrow strip of abrasive paper that only cuts in the middle of the sole.)
The grid on the sole is important for seeing how it is going, but it is good to check with a straightedge and feeler gauge as well. It is hard to explain, but after flattening a few soles you get a feel for how to hold and press to correct small deviations.
Vacuum the paper as soon as filings collect on it, and change it often.
Six or seven sheets of 80 grit later the sole was flat, and I continued refining it with 120, 240 and 400. I also carefully went over the sides to remove some rust and discolouration.
To finish, I polished the sole thoroughly with Autosol on 0000 steel wool and applied a little liquid hard wax. I use ordinary car wax.
Finally it was just a matter of cleaning the plane thoroughly, honing the iron and trying it out.
I use a Lie-Nielsen iron in this plane because it is both a little thicker and holds its edge longer. Here I used three stones: a concave diamond stone (about 600 grit), which gives a slight camber to the iron, a Japanese 1200 stone and a Japanese 8000 stone. Since the purpose of this particular plane is to plane difficult wood with less risk of tear-out, I also hone a 25-degree back bevel on the iron. That gives an effective cutting angle of 70 degrees (25 + the plane’s 45), which is enough for most things. Otherwise you have to get out the card scraper.
Share this content