Search on blog

Buy a Gift Card

Oil Stones Are Nice

The Plane Doctor
star
star
star
star
star
Be the first to rate

A while ago I got two oil stones to try out: a “Soft Arkansas” and a “Hard Black Arkansas”. They correspond roughly to 1000 and 4000 in water stones. After flattening them with a blue diamond stone I tried them on a couple of different chisels and plane irons, and I must say I like the way they feel. They give good feedback on how the steel is being removed and how the honing is progressing. Rumour has it that oil stones are slow, but I don't experience that in any way other than that polishing takes a little longer on the black stone than on a water stone. It is nice to avoid all the sloshing water that Japanese water stones bring, and having to flatten them every five minutes. So all in all, oil stones are probably a little faster. I will probably use oil stones for most of my honing from now on. The exceptions will be when a new blade needs to be prepared and when I need a super-sharp edge and want to polish up to 12000.

For oil I use a mix of about one third paraffin oil and the rest lamp oil, which I keep in my teddy-bear bottle that used to hold honey. A few drops on the stone are enough to help carry away the swarf. Too much oil lubricates a bit too much. The whole point of a sharpening stone is to remove metal, and then you don't want to lubricate away all the friction.

The downside is that a hard black Arkansas is not as fine as an 8000 water stone, so you have to resort to a strop. So far I have used Tormek paste on a piece of MDF, but I am on the hunt for green polishing compound and a suitable piece of leather.

Share this content

0.0 0 votes
Please log in to rate this post

Discover more

Honing With Arkansas Oil Stones
1 January 2016 | The Plane Doctor