Search on blog

Buy a Gift Card

Chinese Plane vs Lie-Nielsen

The Plane Doctor
star
star
star
star
star
Be the first to rate

At last a little time in the garage and a little time to write on the blog. A while ago I borrowed a Chinese-made plane to see how it compares with the Lie-Nielsen model it tries to imitate. Here are some observations and views. It is a smoothing plane of the usual size, that is, a #4.

Chinese-made No. 4 smoothing plane in a wooden box

The plane arrived well packed in a rather nice wooden box with plenty of padding. The first impression was good. It looks genuine, with a good finish on the machined surfaces and beautiful wood in the knob and tote.

The Chinese plane next to a Lie-Nielsen No. 4

All parts were well oiled and looked good. Compared with my LN #4 it looks basically the same, except that the frog is iron rather than bronze. My LN is also fitted with a 55-degree frog, by the way. (Unfortunately the frogs cannot be swapped between the planes. The slots for the fixing are in different positions.)

In general the castings are marginally thinner and the plane slightly lighter, but it still feels heavy and solid. The iron is about a tenth of a millimetre thinner than the LN's but looks perfectly fine. It took me no more than about ten minutes to get the back completely flat and polished on my Sigma Power stones, 1000 and 6000. A clear pass! I also got a good sharp edge on the iron. I haven't tested how durable it is, but the feel on the stones reminds me of LN and makes me think the iron is A2 steel. If so, it should give a fairly durable edge.

Lateral adjuster on the Chinese plane
Lateral adjuster on the Lie-Nielsen No. 4

The picture on the left shows the lateral adjustment lever on the Chinese plane and the one on the right shows the lever on my LN. Here there is a big difference in quality. The Lie-Nielsen has an adjuster arm that engages the slot in the iron with a rotating round disc, while the other plane has a stamped piece of sheet metal. Quality versus cheap!

I also checked how flat the sole is by standing the plane on a sheet of glass and checking with feeler gauges. I couldn't find anywhere my 0.05 mm gauge would fit between the plane and the glass. So the plane is flat from the factory. Good!

Thin shaving from the Chinese plane

With a freshly sharpened iron and a little adjustment, it can take a thin, fine shaving, as you can see.

In summary, it is a good plane, much better than a new Stanley. I did find a few signs of carelessness. For example, the hole for the screw that moves the frog back and forth was full of shavings, so the mouth could not be closed enough. Once they were cleaned out it worked better. The depth adjustment knob has considerable backlash. It takes two full turns after moving the iron outwards before it takes up the slack and the iron starts to move outwards.

Share this content

0.0 0 votes
Please log in to rate this post